
The Greatest Question
1919 · United States · 80 min
- Director
- D. W. Griffith, Stanner E.V. Taylor
- Screenplay
- Stanner E.V. Taylor
- Producer
- Stanner E.V. Taylor
- Cinematography
- Billy Bitzer
- Editing
- James Smith
- Production company
- First National Pictures
Cast
What it is about
Nellie Jarvis, the daughter of traveling parents, witnesses as a child the murder of an elderly woman at the hands of the Scrubbles. Years later she returns to the same community, now an orphan, and is taken in by the poor Hilton family, whose son Jimmie becomes her suitor. To help the household, Nellie takes a job at a nearby farm, where she suffers abuse. The film is a drama with a spiritualist slant, in which faith and justice play a central role.
How it was made
The film is based on a novel by William Hale. Stanner E.V. Taylor is credited as writer and producer, while direction is credited to D. W. Griffith together with Taylor. Billy Bitzer, a frequent Griffith collaborator, handled the cinematography, and James Smith edited. The production company was First National Pictures. The cast includes Lillian Gish, George Fawcett and Robert Harron. Running 80 minutes, it is an American silent drama from 1919.
Reception and legacy
The sources consulted do not provide reliable information on its critical reception or any awards. Its interest for historians lies mainly in its place within the filmographies of Griffith and Gish during the postwar period, and in its attempt at melodrama with spiritualist elements.
Stills



Full film
More films by D. W. Griffith
Original Cinematopedia text based on Wikipedia (en) and Wikidata.
The Birth of a Nation
Intolerance
San Francisco
Broken Blossoms
Way Down East
Orphans of the Storm