Different from You and Me
Anders als du und ich
1957 · Germany · 91 min
- Director
- Veit Harlan
- Screenplay
- Hans Giese, Felix Lützkendorf
- Producer
- Gero Wecker
- Music
- Erwin Halletz
- Cinematography
- Kurt Grigoleit
- Editing
- Walter Wischniewsky
Cast
What it is about
In late-1950s West Germany, the parents of seventeen-year-old Klaus Teichmann grow increasingly worried about the company their son keeps. Their concern centers on Boris Winkler, an antiques dealer who introduces young people to electronic music and modern art. After a complaint against him fails for lack of evidence, Klaus's mother takes a drastic step to steer her son back onto what she sees as the right path, and the story turns into a study of the consequences of that decision and of the social pressure surrounding homosexuality.
How it was made
Based on an idea by Robert Pilchowski, the film was shot between May 8 and June 3, 1957, and directed by Veit Harlan, whose earlier work included the antisemitic propaganda film Jud Süß made under the Nazis. Felix Lützkendorf's screenplay, originally titled Eltern klagen an, was meant as a warning about homosexuality, but Harlan pushed for a more nuanced view that separated people who are homosexual by nature from those who act criminally. A homosexual emancipation activist served as scientific adviser, hoping to shift public opinion toward reforming the law. The film premiered in Vienna as Das dritte Geschlecht, while in West Germany the FSK rating body initially blocked its release.
Reception and legacy
The FSK barred its West German release, judging it too sympathetic toward homosexuality. After cuts, reshoots and redubbing, a second version titled Anders als du und ich. §175 was approved; it was generally seen as homophobic. Critics were harsh: Film-dienst called it a late product of fascism, and the Heyne-Filmlexikon dismissed it as infamous. It is now studied as a case of censorship and as an example of the contradictions of its director, and the 2006 DVD release includes both versions for comparison.
Stills



Trivia
Two versions
Two different cuts were made: the original, which screened in Austria as Das dritte Geschlecht, and a second one approved for viewers over eighteen, with reshot scenes and redubbed dialogue.
Parallel with Jud Süß
Some critics of the time argued that the film repeated, in relation to homosexuality, the kind of rhetoric Harlan had used against Jews in his propaganda work.
More films by Veit Harlan
Original Cinematopedia text based on Wikipedia (es) and Wikipedia (en) and Wikidata.
Jud Süß
Kolberg
The Great King
The Ruler