Cinematopedia
Español
Poster: The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes (1939)
Poster: TMDB · Image rights notice
1930scrime filmmystery film

The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes

1939 · United States · 76 min

Director
Alfred L. Werker
Screenplay
William Gillette, Edwin Blum
Producer
Darryl F. Zanuck
Music
Robert Russell Bennett
Cinematography
Leon Shamroy
Editing
Robert Bischoff
Production company
20th Century Studios
Based on
Sherlock Holmes

What the critics say

89 % Rotten Tomatoes positive reviews

Cast

What it is about

Moriarty walks out of the Old Bailey a free man, acquitted for lack of evidence, and trades barbed remarks with Sherlock Holmes on the steps. Soon after, Ann Brandon visits Baker Street with a sinister drawing of a man bearing an albatross around his neck, the same warning her father received years earlier. Holmes takes the case despite skepticism from those around him, and he also agrees to watch over a valuable gem bound for the Tower of London. With Watson at his side, the investigation grows tangled with moves that seem designed to mislead him.

How it was made

The film is the second of fourteen Sherlock Holmes pictures made between 1939 and 1946, starring Basil Rathbone and Nigel Bruce. Although it claims to adapt William Gillette's stage play, it bears little resemblance to it beyond the rivalry with Moriarty. Producer Darryl F. Zanuck wanted to showcase the detective's best-known traits, among them his violin playing, deductive reasoning and morphine habit. It was the last entry in the series made by Fox and the last set in Doyle's Victorian era, since later films moved to Universal and contemporary settings. In the play's first London production, a very young Charlie Chaplin played Billy; here the role goes to Terry Kilburn.

Reception and legacy

Critics responded positively, and Rotten Tomatoes lists a perfect approval rating, though based on only seven reviews. Its most enduring legacy is the line 'Elementary, my dear Watson', which the American Film Institute ranked 65th among its movie quotes, even though the phrase never appears in a canonical Doyle story. The scene in which Holmes plays the violin to deal with a fly was recreated in the 2009 film starring Robert Downey Jr., and the BBC series cites the Rathbone films as a primary inspiration.

Stills

The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, stills 1The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, stills 2The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, stills 3

Trivia

Chaplin on stage

In the play's first London production, a very young Charlie Chaplin played Billy, the role that Terry Kilburn takes on in this film.

A recreated scene

The scene in which Holmes plays the violin while experimenting with flies was recreated in the 2009 film with Robert Downey Jr.

More films by Alfred L. Werker

Original Cinematopedia text based on Wikipedia (es) and Wikipedia (en) and Wikidata.