Cinematopedia
Español
Poster: Milk (2008)
Poster: TMDB · Image rights notice
2000sdrama filmbiographical filmLGBTQ-related film

Milk

2008 · United States · 128 min

Director
Gus Van Sant
Screenplay
Dustin Lance Black, Brandon Boyce
Producer
Bruce Cohen, Dan Jinks
Music
Danny Elfman
Cinematography
Haris Savides
Editing
Elliot Graham
Production company
Focus Features

Awards: Academy Award for Best Writing, Original Screenplay; Academy Award for Best Actor; National Board of Review: Top Ten Films; Producers Guild Stanley Kramer Award · 8 nominations

What the critics say

93 % Rotten Tomatoes positive reviews83 Metacritic /100

Cast

What it is about

Harvey Milk, a New Yorker nearing forty, has grown restless with his life until he meets a much younger man and decides to start over. The two settle in San Francisco and open a camera shop in Eureka Valley, a working-class neighborhood that is slowly becoming a gay enclave known as the Castro. Behind the counter, Milk discovers that the skills he learned as a shopkeeper help him reach neighbors and organize a community that wants to be seen. He gradually drifts into local public life, clashing with institutions and with gay leaders he considers too cautious, and he launches a series of election campaigns that eventually win him a seat in city government. The film follows that path through the alliances, rivalries and personal bonds that sustain it, paying close attention to the romantic relationships strained by his commitment to politics. The story mixes the rhythm of the campaigns with intimate scenes and period footage, reminding viewers that every public step carried risk. It is an ensemble portrait, with collaborators, friends and opponents filling out the picture of San Francisco in the 1970s.

How it was made

The project went through a long series of false starts. In early 1991, Oliver Stone planned to produce, though not direct, a film about Milk, and he wrote a script called The Mayor of Castro Street. In July 1992, Gus Van Sant signed with Warner Bros. to direct a biopic with Robin Williams in the lead, but by April 1993 the director had parted ways with the studio over creative differences. Rob Cohen was later signed to direct and wrote a script, yet Williams decided it was not right for him and the project stalled. Richard Gere, Daniel Day-Lewis, Al Pacino and James Woods were among the actors considered for Harvey Milk at various points. In April 2007 the project regained momentum when Van Sant sought to direct a script by Dustin Lance Black, while Bryan Singer was developing a separate version that had fallen into development trouble. Sean Penn was attached to the title role, and Matt Damon to the role of Dan White, but Damon withdrew over scheduling conflicts and Josh Brolin took the part in December 2007, joining Emile Hirsch, Alison Pill and James Franco. Focus Features backed the production. Filming began on location in San Francisco in January 2008 and wrapped in March of that year. To recreate the era, the production design and costume teams spent several weeks in the archives of the GLBT Historical Society, reviewing photographs, films, newspapers, historic textiles and ephemera, along with personal belongings of Milk donated by the estate of Scott Smith. They also spoke with people who had known Milk and dressed Castro Street to match the 1970s setting. The filmmakers took over the former camera shop, by then a gift store, for several weeks during production. Filming took place at San Francisco City Hall, but White's office was rebuilt elsewhere because the building's offices had been modernized. Danny Elfman composed the score, and the soundtrack includes period songs such as David Bowie's Queen Bitch and Judy Garland's Over the Rainbow. Harris Savides handled the cinematography and Elliot Graham edited the film, aiming for a texture close to documentary without giving up classical storytelling.

Reception and legacy

Milk was met with wide critical praise. On Rotten Tomatoes, roughly 94 percent of reviews were positive, and on Metacritic the film scored around 83 or 84 out of 100. Todd McCarthy of Variety singled out Sean Penn's performance as the most striking element and praised the film for avoiding the tone of agitprop. Kirk Honeycutt of The Hollywood Reporter argued that it transcended conventional genres as a deeply human document about the need for hope, and he noted that the screenplay, based on Black's own research and interviews, showed in its richness of anecdote. A. O. Scott of The New York Times compared it to a calmer Oliver Stone film, stripped of hyperbole. Not every voice was favorable. John Podhoretz, writing for the conservative Weekly Standard, criticized the portrayal of Milk and the omissions regarding his private life, while the journalist Richard David Boyle, who described himself as a former political ally of Milk, praised the effort to recreate the period and the humanity of the lead actor, though he regretted that the film did not tell the full story of Milk's election. At the Academy Awards, Milk received eight nominations, including Best Picture, and it won two: Best Original Screenplay for Dustin Lance Black and Best Actor for Sean Penn. It also won Independent Spirit Awards and a Writers Guild award for its original screenplay, and it earned BAFTA nominations. Its opening in San Francisco on October 28, 2008, coincided with the campaign around California's Proposition 8, which gave the film an added political resonance. In Samoa, the censorship board banned its distribution in 2009, arguing that it conflicted with Christian beliefs and Samoan culture. Over time, Milk has become one of the most recognized biographical films about the struggle for gay rights, and an example of how cinema can bring back to public memory a figure who was uncomfortable for official narratives.

Stills

Milk, stills 1Milk, stills 2Milk, stills 3

Trailer

Clicking loads the video from YouTube (privacy-enhanced mode). Open on YouTube

More films by Gus Van Sant

Original Cinematopedia text based on Wikipedia (es) and Wikipedia (en) and Wikidata.